https://www.screencast.com/t/ug0wMkYr6
So, if discovered as Member or Guest, suggest that they login first?
Where is that dead horse. I want to kick it one more time.
Um...
My comment was, that Email is recognized as Member, so should be required to login.
Second question you are asking is, should we also require Guests to login. I'm sure we already resolved this question, but I don't remember how. I do recall arguing that requiring Guests to login created an unnecessary obstacle. Seems like you had a counter argument that prevailed, but I don't remember what it was.
I kept suggesting that we just ask, "Is this you." You didn't like that. I was concerned that they would get frustrated and not Register. If we are going to archive Guest Certificates, then we need to confirm their identity, so yes--they have to login.
Does that resolve it?